WATER
2Secret Guards of the Ice Barrier
Archetype:
Ice Barrier
ATK:
100
DEF:
1600
View:
3402
Face-up "Ice Barrier" monsters you control cannot be targeted by effects of your opponent's Effect Monsters.
Secret Guards of the Ice Barrier — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 48 ± 8 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 47 · Deck: 48 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Floodgate/Control · Secondary: Utility
Why it scores here
Secret Guards of the Ice Barrier converts one archetype-locked continuous effect into a persistent protective umbrella: face-up "Ice Barrier" monsters you control cannot be targeted by the opponent's Effect Monster effects. That is real defensive value, but it is soft — it stops only targeting monster effects, not non-targeting removal, Spells/Traps, or board wipes — and it generates no card advantage, no disruption of the opponent's plays, and no board presence of its own (100 ATK, Level 2). Its modest ceiling is driven almost entirely by it being a cheap, searchable one-of tech inside Ice Barrier (avg 1.03 copies in 106 decks), not by any combo or stat line; the 1600 DEF and the archetype's long tail earn nothing on their own.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 55 | It is a Level 2 Ice Barrier monster, so it is fetchable within the archetype via cards like Medallion of the Ice Barrier (co-deck 68.9%), but it lives only in that archetype (inferred). |
| Combo & Conversion | 15 | The text is a passive protection clause with no board-building function and combo data records 0 appearances, so it contributes no combo extension on its own (verified). |
| Resource Economy | 40 | The effect costs nothing but also generates no cards, no searches, and no refuel, leaving it roughly neutral (inferred). |
| Effect & Interaction | 42 | It only denies opponent's Effect Monster targeting of your face-up Ice Barrier monsters, leaving spells, traps, non-targeting effects, and mass removal untouched — situational, soft protection (verified). |
| Material Utility | 48 | As a Level 2 WATER Aqua body it can still be used as material or archetype/name fodder even when its protection is irrelevant, though the 100 ATK body is otherwise weak (inferred). |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 45 | It shields the board while it remains, but has no self-protection and no graveyard or multi-zone function, so a single removal ends the protection (inferred). |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 68 | Runs as an essentially frictionless one-of (avg 1.03 copies, 103 of 106 decks at 1 copy) with no lock or garnet cost (observed). |
Calculation
Weight profile: 0.7 Floodgate/Control + 0.3 Utility (default). Intrinsic ≈ 47, Deck ≈ 48, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: none. Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck
Strengths
- Prevents opponent's Effect Monster effects from targeting your face-up Ice Barrier monsters.
- Searchable inside the archetype (e.g. Medallion of the Ice Barrier), so it is easy to access when needed.
- Extremely cheap to slot — played as a one-of (avg 1.03 copies) with no restriction, lock, or garnet risk.
- Protection is live for all face-up Ice Barrier monsters you control, not just itself.
Weaknesses
- Archetype-locked — does nothing for non-Ice Barrier decks.
- Only blocks targeting by opponent's Effect Monster effects; Spells, Traps, non-targeting effects, and board wipes ignore it.
- Generates no card advantage, no disruption, and no pressure of its own.
- Minimal body (Level 2, 100 ATK) with no graveyard or multi-zone function.
- No combo evidence — pure defensive tech that does not advance a win plan.
Counters / choke points
- Non-targeting removal (cards that remove without choosing a target)
- Spell/Trap-based removal that targets
- Board wipes and mass removal
- Negating or removing Secret Guards itself before it shields the field
Best use
Defensive protection tech / one-of control piece. Decks: Ice Barrier. Suggested copies: 1.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Card text: face-up "Ice Barrier" monsters you control cannot be targeted by effects of your opponent's Effect Monsters.; Card is a Level 2 WATER Aqua Effect Monster with 100 ATK / 1600 DEF belonging to the Ice Barrier archetype.; Legal in TCG, OCG, MasterDuel, and DuelLinks.
- Observed: Runs in 106 decks, all in the main deck, at avg 1.03 copies (103 decks at exactly 1 copy).; Most common archetypes: Ice Barrier variants (37.7% + 14.2% + 2.8%) plus Icejade, Spright, Nimble, Melffy at 8.5% each.; Highest co-deck partners include Freezing Chains of the Ice Barrier (99.1%) and Medallion of the Ice Barrier (68.9%).; Zero combo appearances recorded (appearance rate 0).
- Inferred: Being an Ice Barrier monster makes it fetchable by archetype searchers such as Medallion of the Ice Barrier.; Protection is soft: it does not stop non-targeting monster effects, Spells/Traps, or mass removal.; It provides no card advantage, disruption, or combo extension, functioning as a defensive tech slot.
- Data gaps: no combos supplied — combo conversion is text-only inference no guides supplied no banlist token — assumed 3 copies (unlimited) no usage statistics (StatisticsCard) — archetype inclusion % inferred from deck sample only avg power index / starter count when present unavailable due to zero combo appearances






